top of page

Seidel Aberrations:
Mathematical Formulation and Physical Interpretation

…(SA)

This page introduces Seidel aberration, a third-order aberration of lens systems, based on the paraxial optics theory constructed using (PX) . Seidel aberration expresses the deviation from paraxial imaging as a third-order term in pupil coordinates and object point coordinates, and is decomposed into five types of fundamental aberrations. Below, we show the expression for Seidel aberration and explain the properties of the aberrations represented by each term and their effects on image formation.

table of contents:

・Mathematical expression of Seidel aberration

Let θ be a general term for quantities related to the angle of a light ray, including the angle of incidence i, the angle of refraction i', and the angle u with the optical axis. Then, sinθ and cosθ can be expressed by Taylor expansion as follows.

ザイデル収差_033.png

In the paraxial theory presented on other pages, we have only used the first term of these series expansions to simplify calculations.

ザイデル収差_034.png

This page performs ray tracing while retaining terms up to the third order of the Taylor expansion.

ザイデル収差_035.png

At this point, a discrepancy arises between the ray path obtained by paraxial theory and the ray path obtained by ray tracing that considers up to the third order. This discrepancy from the ideal imaging position is called an aberration. Furthermore, the description of this aberration using the third-order approximation is called Seidel aberration.

However, the paraxial approximation is applied to ω, which is used as the field of view of the object, and it is treated as follows.

ザイデル収差_036.png

From here, we will derive the Seidel aberration based on the theoretical framework used in (PX) . The theoretical model is shown below.

ザイデル収差_005.png

Here, in order to describe aberrations, we introduce the following variables that represent the height and direction of the light rays.

η: Ray height in the front principal plane

ω: Field of view of the object

y: object height

ρ: Ray height at the entrance pupil

φ: Rotation coordinate relative to the y-axis

Furthermore, in order to normalize these variables, the following representative values are defined for each variable.

hˉ : Representative value of ray height at the front principal point

ωˉ : Representative value of the field of view on the object side.

Y: Representative value used for normalizing object height

ρˉ : Representative value of the height of a ray at the entrance pupil.

 

In this case, the range of possible values for the normalized variable can be expressed as follows:

ザイデル収差_006.png

Furthermore, the following standards introduced in (PX) will be applied.

ザイデル収差_007.png

ρ and η are both quantities that describe rays reaching the first plane, and represent the ray heights at the entrance pupil plane and the front principal point plane, respectively. Using the similarity relationship shown in the figure, the following linear relationship holds between them.

ザイデル収差_008.png

y and Y are quantities that represent the ray height in the front principal point plane, and are described by the field of view ω and the normalized field of view ωˉ, respectively. From the paraxial geometry of the figure, the following relationship holds between them.

ザイデル収差_009.png

Here, aberration can be understood as the accumulation of tiny contributions that occur sequentially at each refractive surface. Therefore, the transverse and longitudinal aberrations at the final image plane are expressed as the sum of the aberration contributions generated at each surface.

ザイデル収差_010.png

When the aberration contribution occurring at the j-th plane is expanded to the third order, the transverse aberration component is given by the following equation.

ザイデル収差_011.png

Here, Ij, IIj, IIIj, Pj, and Vj are Seidel coefficients on the j-th plane, representing the magnitudes of spherical aberration, coma aberration, astigmatism, field curvature, and distortion, respectively. The sum of each Seidel coefficient across all optical planes is called the Seidel sum.

In particular, Pj is the Seidel coefficient representing the Petzval curvature, and its Seidel sum is called the Petzval sum.

Although not explicitly stated in the formula, IVj = IIIj + Pj is sometimes treated as the Seidel coefficient for field curvature.

Furthermore, from (1)-②-3 and (1)-④b, the following inequalities hold.

ザイデル収差_012.png

To evaluate the aberration contribution on the image plane, we introduce the tilt of the principal ray on the image side, which is determined by paraxial imaging. From the definition of the paraxial quantity, the following relationship holds.

ザイデル収差_030.png

From the figure and (1)-⑨, the following can be obtained.

ザイデル収差_031.png

Substituting (1)-⑧a,b into this, we obtain the following result.

ザイデル収差_032.png

The values Ij to Vj appearing in (1)-⑧ are coefficients that describe the aberration characteristics of the j-th plane and are determined by the lens shape and refractive index distribution. Below, we introduce intermediate quantities to evaluate these coefficients.

ザイデル収差_015.png

Furthermore, from the results derived in (PX) , sH,j , sP,j , and s'H,j can be expressed as follows.

ザイデル収差_017.png

Using these, Ij to Vj can be expressed as follows:

ザイデル収差_019.png

From the above, it was found that the aberration contribution of the j-th surface can be described using coefficients Ij to Vj, which are determined by the lens shape and refractive index change. By substituting these coefficients into equation (1)-⑧a,b,c,d, it becomes possible to systematically evaluate the contribution of each refractive surface to transverse and longitudinal aberrations.

Furthermore, Ij to Vj are fundamental quantities representing the contribution of each aberration term, and each corresponds to a component of the Seidel aberration. Therefore, by clarifying the physical meaning of these coefficients, we can understand the mechanism of each aberration.

Below, we will examine each term from Ij to Vj in order and show the aberration components they represent.

・Interpretation of Seidel aberrations

[1] Spherical aberration

If we take the terms proportional to η³ for lateral aberration and the terms proportional to η² for longitudinal aberration (i.e., the first term of each) from equation (1)-⑧a, b, c, d, we obtain the following equation.

ザイデル収差_018.png

To understand the characteristics of spherical aberration, the relationship between equation (2)-①b and d can be illustrated as follows.

ザイデル収差_020.png

Thus, the longitudinal aberration Δz' increases in proportion to the square of the ray height η. In other words, the image formation position does not coincide for rays passing near the optical axis and rays passing in the periphery, and the shift in image formation position becomes larger for rays in the periphery. This phenomenon is called spherical aberration. The same relationship holds for the y-direction as well.

Furthermore, none of equations (2)-①a to d include the field of view angle ω. Therefore, the magnitude of spherical aberration does not depend on the field of view and is constant across the entire field of view.

[2] Coma aberration

If we take the terms proportional to (n1tan⁡ω)η² for lateral aberration and the terms proportional to (n1tan⁡ω)η for longitudinal aberration (i.e., the second term in each case) from equation (1)-⑧a, b, c, d, we obtain the following equation.

ザイデル収差_021.png

To understand the characteristics of coma aberration, the relationship between a and b in equation (2)-②, which represents lateral aberration, can be illustrated as follows.

ザイデル収差_022.png

Thus, lateral aberration exhibits a comet-like spread with a vertex angle of 60°, centered at the paraxial imaging position. Furthermore, since the magnitude of this spread is proportional to tanω (ω under the paraxial condition), it increases linearly as the image height increases. The aberration formed by this comet-like distribution is called coma aberration.

[3] Field curvature and astigmatism

If we take the terms proportional to (n1tan⁡ω)²η in the case of lateral aberration and the terms proportional to (n1tan⁡ω)² in the case of longitudinal aberration (i.e., the third term in each case) from equation (1)-⑧a, b, c, d, we obtain the following equation.

ザイデル収差_025.png

To simplify the diagram, we will set it up as follows.

ザイデル収差_026.png

To understand the characteristics of field curvature and astigmatism, the relationship between c and d in equation (2)-③, which represents longitudinal aberration, is illustrated as follows.

ザイデル収差_027.png

Δz' is proportional to (n1tanω)² and does not depend on the ray height η. Therefore, rays originating from the same point converge to a single point in the meridional and sagittal planes, respectively, regardless of their position on the pupil. However, the image formation position shifts along the optical axis according to the field of view ω, so the best image plane is not a plane but a curved surface. This phenomenon is called image field curvature.

On the other hand, the coefficients of longitudinal aberration in the meridional direction (y direction) and the sagittal direction (x direction) are (3 IIIj + Pj ) and (IIIj + Pj ), respectively, so the image formation position does not coincide in both directions. Therefore, the image point does not form at a single point, and as a result, two focal lines are formed: a meridional focal line and a sagittal focal line. This phenomenon is called astigmatism.

As can be seen from the formula, Pj contributes only to field curvature because it moves the meridional and sagittal image planes in the same direction. On the other hand, IIIj contributes to both field curvature and astigmatism because it changes both image planes by different amounts.

[4] Distortion

If we take the terms proportional to (n1tan⁡ω)³ for lateral aberration and the terms proportional to (n1tan⁡ω)³η⁻¹ for longitudinal aberration (i.e., the fourth term in each case) from equation (1)-⑧a, b, c, d, we obtain the following equation.

ザイデル収差_037.png

However, distortion is an aberration that appears as a shift in the image formation position within the image plane, and does not cause a focus shift in the optical axis direction. Therefore, although a term corresponding to longitudinal aberration can be defined, it does not have essential meaning in the evaluation of distortion.

Therefore, in order to understand the characteristics of distortion, if we illustrate only equation (2)-④a, which represents lateral aberration, it will look like this.

ザイデル収差_038.png

Since Δy'j,V does not depend on η, the rays converge to the same point on the y' axis regardless of the ray height η. On the other hand, since Δy'j,V is proportional to tan³ω (≈ω³ for small field of view), it increases rapidly with increasing field of view ω. In other words, although the rays converge to the same point on the y' axis, the deviation from the paraxial image position increases rapidly with increasing image height. Therefore, this aberration can be said to be a highly field-of-view dependent aberration that becomes more pronounced with increasing image height.

In this article, we have summarized the mathematical expression of Seidel aberration and its physical meaning. Seidel aberration theory provides a useful theoretical framework for understanding the generation mechanisms and interrelationships of various aberrations in optical systems. On the other hand, in actual optical systems, the effects of higher-order aberrations are often not negligible, and Seidel aberration alone may not adequately describe the behavior of aberrations. Nevertheless, Seidel aberration remains important as a starting point for understanding the essential structure of aberrations and is a fundamental concept when learning modern aberration analysis and optical design.

Calculation format

The Excel format for calculating the Seidel coefficient, as shown above, is provided below.

Note that this format is on a separate page (PX) This also includes calculations based on the paraxial theory derived earlier.

  • Related Topics

For more information on the paraxial theory framework that forms the basis of Seidel aberrations, please refer to the following.

  • References

[1] Kishikawa, Toshiro. Yūzā Enjinia no Tame no Kōgaku Nyūmon (An Introduction to Optics for User Engineers). Optronics Co.

  • Update History

  • 2026-11: Newly released

If you have any questions, comments, or concerns regarding the content, please contact us here.

bottom of page